For years, self-managed super fund (SMSF) trustees have relied on informal or conservative property valuations—often from local real estate agents or council land assessments—purely to meet compliance requirements. But with the incoming Division 296 tax on super balances above $3 million, that casual approach is no longer viable.
From 1 July 2025, unrealised capital gains on super balances over $3 million will be taxed at an additional 15%. This means that annual property valuations—whether for residential or commercial holdings—will directly impact the amount of tax payable each year. The implications for SMSF members are significant, and the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has already flagged this as a key area of focus.
Why It Matters
Previously, the valuation of SMSF-owned property was mostly a box-ticking exercise. But now, the value placed on a property each financial year will help determine whether your super balance exceeds the $3 million threshold and how much tax is owed on any unrealised capital gain above that level.
Some trustees have already begun adjusting their valuation strategies:
-
Those just under the $3 million mark may look for conservative valuations to avoid triggering the tax.
-
Others, who are well above the threshold, may prefer a higher valuation before 30 June 2025. This would establish a higher base value, reducing future unrealised gains and therefore limiting tax exposure.
But switching between inflated and deflated valuations each year to manage tax liabilities isn’t just risky—it can attract ATO scrutiny and result in penalties, interest, and broader audits across your tax affairs.
The ATO is Paying Attention
The ATO has made clear it will be paying closer attention to SMSFs, particularly those with large balances and property holdings. It’s also worth noting that ASIC has taken disciplinary action against 17 SMSF auditors in the second half of 2024, which means auditors are now under pressure to ensure the integrity of property valuations they sign off on.
Valuations that are inconsistent, unsubstantiated, or appear strategically low or high from year to year may raise red flags. Trustees found to be manipulating values could face not only additional tax assessments, but also fines or disqualification.
What Is a “Robust” Valuation?
A legitimate, defensible valuation is one that reflects true market value—what the property would likely sell for today. Ideally, this is prepared by a qualified independent valuer, especially for commercial property, where comparable sales and rental benchmarks are harder to find.
Professional valuation reports typically include:
-
Full property inspection
-
Comparable market analysis
-
Assessment of rental yields, size, quality, and condition
-
Local market trends and zoning considerations
While residential properties may be easier to value with comparable sales data, commercial properties—especially those leased to related entities—require more caution. For instance, if your business is renting property from your SMSF and paying above-market rent, this may have historically been a strategy to boost super contributions. However, overstated rents can lead to inflated valuations, triggering greater tax exposure under the new rules.
What You Should Do
-
Review Your Super Balance: If you’re near or above the $3 million threshold, start planning now for how this tax may apply to you.
-
Engage a Qualified Valuer: Especially for commercial property, avoid relying on informal agent opinions or outdated valuations.
-
Be Consistent: Avoid alternating between conservative and inflated valuations depending on the tax year. The ATO is watching for patterns.
-
Review Rental Arrangements: If your SMSF holds property leased to related parties, make sure rental rates are commercially justifiable.
Final Thought
While the tax on unrealised gains is controversial and likely to remain a point of political debate, it’s the law from 1 July 2025. Trying to manipulate valuations to game the system isn’t worth the risk—and could lead to ATO scrutiny well beyond your SMSF. Now is the time to ensure your property valuations are defensible, your documentation is sound, and your strategy is aligned with the new reality.
If you would like help reviewing your SMSF structure or property valuation approach, please reach out to Cadre Capital Partners for assistance.